DIY Bathroom Renovation vs. Hiring a Contractor: A Cost, Time & Quality Comparison

When your outdated bathroom is starting to look tired, a remodel feels like a no-brainer but the real question is: should you take the DIY route or bring in a pro?

We’ve worked on renovation projects big and small, and we’ve seen both sides. Some homeowners love the hands-on experience of a DIY bathroom remodel. Others prefer to hire a contractor to handle the messy details.

This guide will walk you through everything you need to know including labor costs, total time, quality, and hidden challenges, so you can make the smartest choice for your bathroom project.

DIY Bathroom Renovation: Pros and Cons

‍

‍

Pros of a DIY Bathroom Remodel

Doing it yourself can be a rewarding way to save money, especially on a tight budget. Here's what makes DIY appealing:

• Lower DIY bathroom remodel cost: If you already have some power tools and know your way around a level and drill, you can cut out labor costs and stay within your budget.
• Full creative control: You get to choose the bathroom fixtures, tile, layout, and every little detail of your bathroom makeover.
• Sense of accomplishment: There’s real pride in saying, “We did this ourselves.”
• Flexibility and pace: You work on your schedule, which is great if you’re juggling other projects.
• A chance to learn new skills: A step by step guide or YouTube video can help you master everything from cement board installation to shower wall tile.

Cons of DIY Renovation Projects

But let’s be honest, DIY bathroom renovations aren’t all fresh paint and Pinterest wins.

• Time-consuming: It often takes weeks or even months. Every “quick fix” turns into another trip to the hardware store.
• Skill gaps: Plumbing, electrical wiring, and tile work are easy to mess up. Mistakes can lead to leaks, water damage, or worse.
• Hidden costs: That low DIY budget can balloon fast if you uncover mold behind the wall or need to move the toilet.
• No warranty: Unlike a professional remodel, your DIY bathroom won’t come with a guarantee.
• Stressful and messy: Managing everything: demo, design, install, adds serious pressure, especially in a small space like a bathroom.

Hiring a Contractor for Bathroom Remodel: Pros and Cons

‍

‍

Benefits of Hiring a Bathroom Remodeling Contractor

Bringing in a general contractor can feel like a luxury and sometimes, it’s the best choice.

• Professional quality: Contractors deliver polished work that lasts. They know how to install a walk-in shower, fix uneven bathroom floors, and align every tile on your back wall just right.
• Time efficiency: They can finish the job in weeks, not months.
• Stress-free process: You won’t have to coordinate vendors, chase down materials, or redo faulty work.
• Expertise in code compliance: Licensed pros know local building codes, especially for plumbing and electrical wiring.
• Warranty and peace of mind: Most contractors offer warranties, a big plus if you’re concerned about future water damage or resale value.

Downsides of Hiring a Contractor

Still, hiring out isn’t always perfect.

• Higher upfront cost: Labor is the biggest expense in any bathroom remodel. You’ll pay for their expertise.
• Less creative control: While pros follow your vision, you might not have the same hands-on involvement you’d get in a DIY project.
• Finding the right fit: Not all contractors are equal. You’ll need to vet their qualifications, check reviews, and review their bathroom renovation portfolio.

Time Comparison: How Long Does Each Option Take?

DIY Timeline

• A full DIY bathroom renovation may take 4–10 weeks or longer depending on:
• Your experience level
• The size of your bathroom
• Availability of materials and tools
• Unexpected issues (mold, leaks, etc.)

Contractor Timeline

• A bathroom remodeling contractor can typically complete the job in 2–4 weeks, depending on complexity. They have a crew, a plan, and know how to manage finish work efficiently.

Cost Comparison: DIY vs. Contractor
‍

‍

Tip: DIY might save you upfront, but if you need to call a pro to fix a mistake, you could end up paying more in the long run.

Quality Comparison: DIY vs. Contractor Work

DIY Bathroom Quality

If you’re handy and detail-oriented, you might end up with a solid result. But even minor errors: crooked tile, uneven shower walls, leaky faucets, can impact both appearance and function.

Common issues in DIY remodels:

• Uneven flooring
• Misaligned fixtures
• DIY-installed tub that doesn’t drain correctly
• Caulking or paint mistakes that ruin the look

Contractor Quality

Professionals deliver a complete and polished finish. A good bathroom remodel contractor ensures:

• Waterproofing is solid
• Plumbing works flawlessly
• Fixtures are aligned perfectly
• The ceiling, walls, and floors transition cleanly

Which Option Is Right for You?

Ask yourself:

• Do I have time to manage a complex diy bathroom remodel?
• Can I afford to hire a contractor or will I need to cut costs?
• Do I enjoy home decor, hands-on projects, and learning new skills?
• Am I prepared for setbacks, mess, and late nights?

If you want full control, love power tools, and need to save money, DIY might be your path. If you’re short on time and want a functional space that adds value to your home, it might be time to bring in a pro.

Bathroom Renovation Tips for Both Paths

DIY Bathroom Tips

• Start with a step by step guide for layout, demolition, and installation
• Invest in quality tools, especially for plumbing and tile work
• Don’t skip the waterproofing membrane for shower wall tile
• Watch for water damage when you demo the old bathtub or walls
• Be realistic with your time and energy, it’s a marathon, not a sprint

Hiring a Bathroom Contractor Tips

• Get multiple quotes and ask about contractor qualifications
• Look at before-and-after photos of past bathroom projects
• Clarify who handles permits, materials, and cleanup
• Ask about warranties and timelines
• Be involved, but trust their process, micromanaging can slow things down

Final Thoughts: DIY or Contractor? Choose What’s Right for You

A DIY bathroom renovation can be a fun challenge or a stressful headache, depending on your experience and bandwidth. Hiring a bathroom remodel contractor offers expertise and peace of mind at a price.

Either way, updating your outdated bathroom can create a functional space that feels fresh, modern, and totally you. Whether you're painting walls, choosing a double vanity, or installing a new shower, your bathroom makeover is worth the effort.

Need Help With a Bathroom Remodel?

If you're in the Bothell area and looking for professional support, our team at Solid Kitchen & Bath can help you create a custom plan that fits your goals and budget. If you're leaning DIY or full-service, we're happy to offer guidance, product recommendations, or a free quote.

Let’s bring your vision to life.

FAQs

1. Should I DIY or hire a contractor?

Whether you should go for a DIY bathroom renovation or hire a bathroom remodeling contractor depends on your budget, timeline, and experience level. If you're handy with power tools, comfortable with plumbing and electrical work, and want to save money, a DIY bathroom remodel may be a good fit, especially for cosmetic updates or working on a tight budget.

However, for complex remodels involving structural changes, shower installations, or electrical wiring, hiring a general contractor ensures the job meets code, stays on schedule, and delivers professional results. Choose based on how much time, skill, and risk you're willing to take on.

2. Is it cheaper to remodel a bathroom yourself?

Yes — a DIY bathroom remodel is often cheaper than hiring a contractor because you eliminate labor costs, which are one of the biggest expenses in a remodel. DIYers can reduce the total cost significantly by handling demolition, painting, or installing bathroom fixtures like faucets and vanities themselves.

However, unexpected issues like water damage, improper plumbing, or errors in tile installation can lead to higher long-term costs. If done correctly, DIY can save thousands, but be sure to factor in tools, time, and the learning curve.

3. Do I need a contractor to remodel my bathroom?

It depends. If your bathroom renovation involves basic updates like replacing bathroom fixtures, applying a fresh coat of paint, or installing a new faucet, you might be able to handle the project as a DIY bathroom remodel, especially if you're comfortable using power tools and working on a tight budget.

However, if your project includes moving plumbing, installing a walk-in shower, updating electrical wiring, or correcting water damage, hiring a bathroom remodeling contractor is usually the safer route. A general contractor can manage complex tasks, ensure code compliance, and deliver a polished result with fewer delays.

So, the real question is: how confident are you in your skills, time, and budget? If you're unsure, bringing in a pro could save you more in the long run, both in terms of total cost and peace of mind.

4. What is the most expensive part of a bathroom remodel?

The most expensive part of a bathroom remodel is typically labor, followed closely by plumbing upgrades and tile installation. Hiring a contractor to redo a bathroom means you'll pay for their expertise, equipment, and crew often accounting for 40–60% of the total cost.

Other high-cost areas include custom shower wall tile, new tubs or soaking tubs, double vanities, and specialty fixtures. Material quality, layout changes, and hidden issues like water damage or outdated wiring can also drive up expenses. Budget carefully and prioritize must-haves to stay on track.